why homestuck is problematic

They dont have a concept of incest and I wouldnt be surprised if they werent bothered by age Gaps either with how impersonal their mating is. Hussie saying that Kanaya's lesbianism is considered a fetish in troll society isn't Hussie saying that he considers lesbianism a fetish. The lesson here is that an abuse victim needed to learn to take life into their own hands sooner. Hussie said he returned to the 140,000 word long draft, cut the story in half, and tried to make it feel like something legitimately worth reading to anyone who crossed the full span of 2020s madness.. How can any story even get written then? Music is so integral to the experience of Homestuck Id argue the story doesnt work without it. Both options ultimately leave someone somewhere dissatisfied. The solid sales performance also lifted the food retailer's profit margins. I don't really care and didn't know about this before I skimmed this but you seriously didn't notice Meenah and HIC talked stereotypically black? On the other hand, Terezi Pyropethe second character with a disability in Homestuckis blind. I came to regard that fandom as being pretty close to a cult. Wo Long: Fallen Dynasty is the latest product to feel the review bomb burn. Why didn't you mention that one? As he comes to better understand and accept himself for who he is, the homophobia fades from his vocabulary, he opens up to people, and allows more of his vulnerabilities to show though. Submit fanart, cosplay and discussions of all kinds! Or you read a lot of Twilight and now you cant escape allure of urban fantasy erotica with alarmingly dubious ideas surrounding consent. Hi. Two friends who realize they see each other as something more I live for that kind of stuff when its done right. I had no idea what Tab was, for example. Actually, my favorite thing about the webcomic: Homestuck is acutely aware that it exists on the Internet, and exploits that fact to its fullest capacity. And then theres this gang war between these black alien mobsters, the Midnight Crew, and a time gang, the Felt, whos boss, Lord English is destined to destroy the multiverse. You can't tell just from what karkat said. The Homestuck following was (and is in many ways still) very involved with the project. Here appears another symptom of ableismthat of the view that persons with disabilities need to be fixed in order to fit in with normal society. And thats the trimmed down version of the trimmed down version. Okay, so the plot hole is also a cue ball and the whole story is pool and chess and I think blackjack. Okay, geez! By the time I was up to date with Homestuck, it was a fair ways in and even then I didn't really participate in the fandom so no event is too big or too obvious to mention. If you have an argument other than deformed kids (which I just said they shouldn't have), go ahead and try to change my mind. But theyre also very upsetting in general. Are many of them flawed? Dirk, though, happens not to subscribe to Uncle Bens mantras about power and responsibility. Yeah, we all have seen that one before. As Zhens, who also goes by Z, crusade grows, she continues to grapple with the responsibility that comes with inspiring such a snowballing movement. This process, known as review-bombing, has been used for both good and bad causes. The Meat/Candy dichotomy is one Hussie developed for himself long before the release of the epilogues. To me, black is just a color. An exciting plot is all fine and good, but no one is buying into that if your characters are nothing but paper puppets, acting in any way that moves the plot forward. (But please, don't jsut say that "it's morally wrong" and then not explain how. This event kickstarts her own story and accelerates the development of her own personal politics. The implosion of Silvergate Bank has a lot to do with the fact that it was crypto's bank of choice. We are currently experiencing a system-wide issue with a delay on all activations. Why else would he made the prison comment? And then Obama shows up. A particularly long entry in a book series can get up to 200 thousand words. But Hussie questions those practices as a form of fandom, and redefines what the word really means today. No idea who that is, I covered incest above and I am 24, so what's your point? and the other half is him being completely oblivious to what the original poster means. used to say caucasian before it was changed to peachy). This fits in with the medical model of ableism, described on stopableism.org as: The power to change disabled people seems to lie with the medical and associated professions, with their talk of cures, normalization, and science.This enormous crime that they do to Tavros is never critiqued or addressed as problematic in any way; instead it is brushed off as being perfectly acceptable, like every other instance of ableism in Homestuck. The [Online Poisoned] often even joke with self awareness about their bad internet habits, but [they] just keep doing it, Hussie said. My ask box is always open for corrections, things I may have missed, or just general discussions of my posts. WebHomestuck, Problem Sleuth, Sweat Bor and Helpful Jed. Artist and writer Andrew Hussie is a reluctant father of internet fandom. I haven't seen a single person defend Zebruh. The player is driven to suicide due to a callout post from cirava after they accuse the player of copying them, Theres a legit slave owner character that the fandom insists on defending no matter what. Yet hes made multiple, incredibly racist characters that are heavily based on disgusting caricatures and stereotypes. Pyscholonials doesnt give in to hopelessness. But Homestuck isn't about fan inclusion for the sake of happy-fun-creating together, it's about WHY we might want to do that and a host of other things. A confirmation hes referring to Kanayas lesbian identity as the fetish he remarked from above. A hole in plot, if you will. The few legitimate criticisms that arent nitpicks or blind virtue signaling arent even all that damning. Kismessitudes really were just abusive relationships (we never saw a healthy example, the "dead ringer" of a black romance, Spades Slick and the troll's Black Queen, has BQ stab Slick in the eye and cut off his hand and Slick later shooters her. In case you don't know what I am talking about: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ojLmFm-WUrCZ7fXALowpiAW7jklCfq14n0Zz1ECdsX0/mobilebasic, https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Z_pA2pfbnyXjxMx4PZm_LNbRSO3cZuZJ2jOOD1RpE0o/edit. "Babyed or harassed"? In this passage, the narrator (or author, Andrew Hussie) describes Tavross experiences in the game. Too bad the post is gone. And then John implies that its maybe Jakes fault for letting it get as bad as it did? I don't really care about homestuck drama, it is a product of its time as another comment said but.. OP seems vastly unaware of a lot of social issues to be "responding" to this drama. And, most problematically, they do so without his consent, waiting until he is asleep to forcibly cut off his legs and replace them with the robolegs. What Hussie describes is a dynamic that we see play out again and again online. Calliope isnt the protagonist to Dirks antagonism, they are equal and opposite forces that corrode the narrative from different directions. It seems that whatever small ways I was able to control that brand, back when I still was interested in doing so, has since become dramatically overwritten by the preposterous hallucinatory projections of a zealous fandom.. He forces Rose to consent to being kidnapped, then makes her wife, Kanaya, blame herself for it all. ._1W1pLIfaIb8rYU6YeTdAk6{margin-right:6px}._1H6Meh6ZAemKxOJDOEasfK{border-radius:50%;box-sizing:border-box;height:20px;margin-left:-8px;width:20px}._1H6Meh6ZAemKxOJDOEasfK:first-child{margin-left:0}._30vlMmCcnqKnXP1t-fzm0e{display:inline-block;margin-left:-8px;position:relative} DISH network users facing authentication or login issues. Gross Margin. They treat the characters of Friendsim and of Homestuck as though theyre all actual adults and write them like that, and just ignore the fact that theyre all like, 13-14 (and BARELY older if they are save for Chahut). 1. To him, a reluctant cult leader will withdraw from the spotlight and rarely address their followers. WebThis process, known as review-bombing, has been used for both good and bad causes. Pedophilia and incest in one fell swoop. Smarter bloggers have tried and failed. The story feels like a retelling of the hell-year that was 2020, but Hussie started drafting the story back when everyone was just starting to be stuck inside for the first time. WebA tale about a boy and his friends and a game they play together. ), heres an approximation of just how insane that is: new writers are advised that the first book the try to publish should be around 6070 thousand words. Wo Long: Fallen Dynasty is the latest product to feel the review bomb burn. Secondly, much of what the document draws attention to are things criticised within the text. To beat the game, they have to interact with the game worlds characters, and with a disgruntled group of internet trolls. I didn't pick up on things like that when I first read Homestuck because I'm from England and didn't watch American 'real life' shows, ie, media set in our world or a variation of it, or listen to genres like rap, hip-hop, etc. I see that like "are you crazy? Haha, the gif is actually still on the server at: http://www.mspaintadventures.com/storyfiles/hs2/scraps/CAUCASIAN.gif. The content vacuum created by a cryptid leader results in overwhelming conditions of parasociality, and the projections of personality, morality, and biographical data onto the blank-slate leader can get ludicrous, and often pretty spiteful. According to the definitions posted above, ableism occurs when society considers the non-disabled as the standard for living, and the disabled are marginalizedand Tavros is constantly marginalized as an other throughout his presence in Homestuck. I asked Hussie if he thinks everyone should just log off. I still maintain that any album with a song entitled Pumpkin Party in Sea Hitlers Water Apocalypse is a good album by default on principle now and forever. Sprouts' operating income surged 20% to $62 million. The music from this one little animation tells the story just as much as anything on screen does. WebKate Mitchell. No one considered it a slur yet. Back then, fans popularized in-character discussions where fans could roleplay characters through an online chat. But it's also a prime example of the hidden insolvency that exists across much of the banking sector. The video, predictably, provoked speculation over the true timeline and events surrounding the games development. Im all for fair criticism, but this aint it. Something went wrong. People dissect drama around his work and become amateur reporters on matters internal to his company. WebMost toxic K-Pop fandoms include ARMY (BTS), EXO (EXOTIC), Twice (Once), and more. I didn't even know that there is a stereotype until now. Some intentional, some not. The fact that they changed it is what's wrong. If so, then there's nothing "wrong" with that, because they had no way of knowing they are related. The way shes written is overly sexualized, more so with her Japanese highschool girl esque- outfits that other characters have commented on. On the damn writing team. As Dirk ascends, though, he gains full awareness of the story itself. While weve seen characters manipulate time before, Lord Englishs control over all of time in all of its forms is so absolute, his presence in the narrative is already guaranteed. Here's a post discussing it. So, no matter how much the story frustrates me or how disappointed I get, I feel like I have to look at it in some way. Likewise Mindfang's joyous rape-and-murder spree of a memoir is discussed in text (And it's never graphic. Hussie: lets go on this journey of discovery together. Regardless, the intense gaze of the man in the thumbnail dares you to go on and see what the hell this is all about. Take later. Is it a bad joke? Do trolls even have races? But Hussie was ready for something new, and in his words, anti-cult.. As the community got larger, and Hussie wanted more control of the story, this eventually petered out, which did distance some of the older problem sleuth fans. While its about revolution, its told in a refreshingly modern and relevant way. Example: MLP makes money not only by merchandising but also by ad sales, etc. As far as controversies contained within the fandom go, there's only one big one that I can think of. 1.4K Takers Personality Quiz. Small business owner, political organizer, and professional writer based in the Puget Sound area. Oh don't worry, I always planned to cover PEACHY. They post in the most inappropriate moments, for example, a tragedy happened, and all of a sudden a K-Pop post pops up in the replies not once but many, many times. 36.87%. Im not sure if fondly is the word Id use here, but I can regard it. I don't think writing off the whole webcomic as worthless because it's 'problematic' is smart either. Obviously, this sort of mockery is considered ableist. A quick search on Reddit reveals dozens of threads discussing questions like What happened to andrew hussie? and other posts tracking the creators activity on social media platforms like Tumblr. Please check your email to find a confirmation email, and follow the steps to confirm your humanity. Like who? I saw a lot of promise in Johns relationship with Roxy. In this sense, fandom itself, with examples like Homestuck, was the precursor to the asymmetrical relationships that have come to characterize so much of online life. OK, but how is that racist? Mainstream content producers can afford to turn a blind eye to smaller copyright infringements (though they can and do take steps to stop them when they are made aware of them!) So Im almost made to feel bad for even entertaining John/Roxy as an idea in the first place if the results were to be this disastrous for everyone involved. Point 3: Homestuck is not delicate or child friendly. Press J to jump to the feed. In my case, that thing I tried to copy when I started out was Homestuck. Eventually, she goes on to write a widely read manifesto; taking the reins of a militant revolutionary group that wears goth clown makeup. Banning from conventions. Some controversy came from the fact that two people donated 10,000 dollars to it to essentially have their fan characters get 1 panel cameos in the comic. Like I oughta. The outfits Jade is wearing is her outfit she wore when she was 13, implying her age in the art. Yet were given both to read. In 2012, around 24,000 backers pledged roughly $2 million to help bring Hiveswap, a video game version of the Homestuck, to life. People actually pull a bigger fit about the fact that it was retconed than they ever did over the original joke. Throughout the course of Psycholonials, there are burning police stations, a revolution against the state, and a global pandemic all mediated through the eyes of a young woman whos trying to survive the fucked up world around her and while calling attention to its problems. The Meat timeline is obviously canon, because for Lord Englishs demise to make any sense, John needed to have gone back and plugged in the missing parts of the story. WebThe plot of Homestuck is infamously convoluted but boils down to: four kids who know each other online play a video game together, inadvertently causing the apocalypse. Its upsetting to read either way. Read it on a computer. Every bit of it is there in order to prepare the troll kids for the game. "Queer Eye" star Karamo Brown recently told INSIDER that he thinks the beloved film about a gay relationship, " Call Me by Your Name ," is "problematic as f---." The counterargument to this is that John, the only character who is 100% confirmed to be canonically straight is very frequently paired with Dave and Karkat.

Field Artillery Battalion Has Four Batteries, Robert M Kaplan South Africa, Vintage Porcelain Music Boxes, Articles W